All About Flex: Polyimide vs. Silicone for Flexible Heaters

Flexible heaters are sub-divided into two primary technology platforms: etched-foil and wire-based technology. Wire-based (wire strands woven together or single strand wire) is the more common technology, with multiple customers offering a wide range of products. Etched foil heaters represent a newer technology (developed in the last 40 years…if that can be considered new!) and are used in more advanced thermal management applications with thickness limitations and multiplanar heated surfaces.  

Flexible etched foil heaters are commonly grouped into categories based on their dielectric type. Three primary types of dielectrics are most common and each have advantages and disadvantages. Heater dielectric categories for this discussion include:  Standard Polyimide, Silicone Rubber and High Temperature Polyimide.

Standard Polyimide

Polyimide is the primary material type chosen when high thermal control is desired with the thinnest construction possible. The amber-colored polyimide is often referred to as Kapton® a trade name of DuPont. Traditional polyimide heaters are constructed with two layers of polyimide film encapsulating an etched metal pattern of a resistive foil layer. The top and bottom polyimide film layers are bonded together using high performance thermoset acrylic adhesive.

Both flame-retardant (FR) grades and non-FR grades of adhesive are available. The polyimide film is rugged and can handle temperatures exceeding 300°C.  The weak link in these constructions is the adhesive system which can become problematic at temperatures >150°C. Polyimide is also excellent for applications requiring low out-gassing.

Silicone Rubber

Silicone rubber (SR) is often utilized for general heater applications and is favored for its overall mechanical properties.  Silicone rubber can be used for outdoor or wet environments and the overall thickness provides better protection from mechanical damage. Silicone rubber is frequently reinforced with a fiberglass grid which provides excellent dimensional stability. Silicone rubber heaters have a higher thermal rating at >230°C. However, SR heaters are less flexible and are not well-suited for component assembly.

Silicone rubber heaters are also much heavier, placing some limits on their ability to be bonded using typical pressure-sensitive adhesives. An attractive bonding option is to mount the silicone rubber heaters directly onto a heat sink using a vulcanizing process. This attachment method uses uncured silicone rubber as the bonding material. Silicone rubber heaters are rugged solutions for industrial and general use applications, but should be avoided when out-gassing is critical.

High Temperature Polyimide

Specialty applications are demanding higher and higher temperature performance from thin and flexible heaters. Downhole oil drilling is frequently mentioned as a particularly extreme high-temperature environment so flexible circuit materials developed for some of these specialty applications have been adopted in high temperature heaters. Advanced polyimide heater constructions have been recently developed and tested to perform well in applications up to 300°C (572°F). Elimination of the adhesive layer within the heater construction is a prerequisite to achieve these performance requirements. Combining these specialty adhesiveless materials with newly developed manufacturing processes can create products with exceptionally high temperature heater performance. 

The chart below provides a comparison among three flexible heater materials. It should be noted these are standard parameters and should be considered safe as guidelines. Exceeding these operating ranges is often possible but consultation with an applications engineer, along with some prototype testing, is recommended.

Dave_DataChart.JPG 

*Continuous Operating Temperatures. 

**Application specific and must be validated by customer.

*** Bond data per 3M specification and test protocol.  Actual data will vary depending on application.

Related Reading:

  1. All Flex Heater Circuit Design Guide
  2. 300C High Temperature Flexible Heaters
  3. Understanding Etched Foil Heaters

Dave Becker is vice president of sales and marketing at All Flex Flexible Circuits LLC.

Back

2018

All About Flex: Polyimide vs. Silicone for Flexible Heaters

02-08-2018

Flexible heaters are sub-divided into two primary technology platforms: etched-foil and wire-based technology. Wire-based (wire strands woven together or single strand wire) is the more common technology, with multiple customers offering a wide range of products.

View Story

All About Flex: Copper Thickness Requirements for Flex Circuits

02-05-2018

An end user will specify the copper thickness of a printed circuit for different reasons. The most obvious reason would be for current-carrying capacity, but copper thickness also directly impacts thermal performance and impedance. All these are vital properties impacting the functionality and reliability of a flexible circuit.

View Story

All About Flex: Copper Grain Direction

01-04-2018

Many materials have different characteristics depending upon the orientation of the material. For example, woven textile materials have a warp and a weft direction. The warp direction is the longitude direction and the weft is the transverse.

View Story
Back

2017

All About Flex: Options for Purchasing Flexible Heaters

11-15-2017

Flexible heaters represent a product technology generically described as thin and flexible heating elements used as attachments to various heat sinks to provide freeze protection, consistent temperatures, and thermal control from -80°C to +230°C and higher.

View Story

All About Flex: More on UAVs and Flexible Circuits

10-30-2017

The use of drones or unmanned aircraft vehicles (UAVs) is growing at a nearly exponential rate. This includes drones used by the government, private companies and hobbyists. If you have $100, you can find a long list of drones for purchase.

View Story

All About Flex: Flexible Circuit Failure Analysis

10-19-2017

Design reviews and early involvement by a circuit board fabrication house can minimize the possibility of field problems, but despite best efforts, there remain occasions when diagnosis of a poorly performing design is required.

View Story

All About Flex: Flexible Circuits for Reusable Medical Products

09-21-2017

Flexible circuits have been used in medical devices and medical instrumentation for several decades. Flex circuits and flexible heaters can be ideal solutions in applications requiring lightweight, continuous movement, and highly reliable interconnections that are biocompatible.

View Story

All About Flex: Flexible Circuits and Man-Made Satellites

09-12-2017

The first satellite was launched by the USSR in 1957. The U.S. successfully launched its first satellite, Explorer 1, in 1958 while announcing the intention to “win” the race to outer space. Today satellites serve many vital purposes.

View Story

All About Flex: Using ZIF Connectors with Flexible Circuits

09-07-2017

Zero insertion force (ZIF) connectors are probably the most popular flexible circuitry connector because they allow the circuit to be inserted and removed multiple times with very little mechanical wear on the copper traces.

View Story

All About Flex: The Anatomy of a Flex Circuit Cutline

08-22-2017

Numerous methods are used to create the cutline of a flexible circuit. With the various tooling options, the methods, process steps, tooling and technology are different. These differences affect the actual physics of cutting, and create slight variations on the circuit material.

View Story

All About Flex: ITAR Registration

08-15-2017

Vendors building product for the defense industry often stipulate a supplier needs to be ITAR registered. ITAR stands for International Traffic in Arms Regulations and is a program run by the U.S. government to control the export of defense-related technology to foreign countries.

View Story

Successful Flex Circuit Assembly

08-02-2017

Many contract manufacturers are reluctant to mix rigid and flexible circuits on the same assembly line as the handling and fixturing requirements can be quite different. Characteristics allowing a flexible circuit to be flexible can often present learning curve challenges when component or mechanical assembly is required. This article details some of the common issues experienced when assembling flexible circuits, and strategies to ensure reliable assembly.

View Story

All About Flex: Button Plating on a Flexible Circuit

07-20-2017

Button plating describes a fabrication process widely used in the flex circuit industry to selectively electroplate copper to the vias and onto the pads capturing the vias. The rest of the copper traces do not have plating. Another industry term used to describe this feature is pads only plating. Producing a circuit with this processing methodology requires two photolithography steps.

View Story
Back

2016

All About Flex: Customer Acquisition

12-22-2016

The “Customer Acquisition” process can be thought of as consisting of three major segments: collection, selection and execution. While these sub-divisions should be considered as intimately interrelated, examining them as separate disciplines can be enlightening.

View Story

All About Flex: Disruption in the Supply Chain

12-08-2016

Manufacturers need a highly dependable supply chain to successfully support their products. This is especially true of custom designed and built components, as many times, only one supplier is available for a component since tooling and development costs discourage dual sourcing.

View Story

All About Flex: Packaging Flexible Circuits and Assemblies

12-01-2016

Many facets are involved in delivering a flexible circuit. During the quote and design phase, requirements are reviewed. So assuming the relevant product documentation was gathered, the salesperson turned around the quote, and the customer placed an order and parts were built, it’s all over, right? Not quite. One critical aspect that does not get much discussion is packaging and shipping.

View Story

All About Flex: Non-Copper Flexible Circuit Applications

11-22-2016

While pure copper is the most common choice for flexible circuit fabrication, there are times a different metal is more suitable for an application. Copper is well known for its excellent electrical and thermal conductivity, but there are applications where the best thermal or electrical conductivity can be a disadvantage.

View Story

All About Flex: Flex Circuit Specifications for Commercial and Military Applications

10-27-2016

Applications across the various markets for printed circuit boards can have significantly different specifications and performance requirements. Circuits for toys and games logically have lower performance requirements than those used in medical devices. IPC-6013 is an industry-driven specification that defines the performance requirements and acceptance features for flexible printed circuit boards.

View Story

All About Flex: Five Characteristics of a Reliable Flexible Circuit Supplier

10-27-2016

Due diligence when selecting a source for a custom electronic product can be a critical sourcing procedure. Chains are only as good as the weakest link, and the electronic components assembled to create a marketable product need to combine into a robust solution.

View Story

All About Flex: Flexible Circuit Prototypes

10-13-2016

Most electronic projects begin with at least one build of prototype parts before moving into volume manufacturing. But the definition of a flex circuit prototype can vary considerably from one project to another. In many cases, a prototype build is only a few parts used to verify form, fit and function, with engineering trying to determine if something actually works.

View Story

Flex Circuit Specifications for Commercial and Military Applications

09-30-2016

Applications across the various markets for printed circuit boards can have significantly different specifications and performance requirements. Circuits for toys and games logically have lower performance requirements than those used in medical devices. IPC 6013 is an industry-driven specification that defines the performance requirements and acceptance features for flexible printed circuit boards.

View Story

All About Flex: Lead-Free Soldering Flexible Circuits

09-23-2016

Ever since the European community adopted the RoHS directive in 2006, the U.S. electronics industry has been steadily increasing its use of lead-free solder. Medical was the first U.S. industry to go totally lead-free. Today, a significant percentage of electronics soldering is done with lead-free solder.

View Story

All About Flex: FAQs on RoHS for Flex Circuits

09-02-2016

In 2003, the European Union (EU) adopted a standard called the Restriction of Hazardous Substances (RoHS), which restricts the use of certain materials in electronic products and electronic equipment. The intent is to reduce the environmental impact of known hazardous materials and has driven changes in manufacturing processes and materials used to manufacture a wide array of electronic products.

View Story
Back

2015

All About Flex: Embracing the Mess

12-03-2015

Marketing in the world of printed circuits is an important discipline, but I have learned it is better to be prepared with a nimble reaction than to expect the marketing department to consistently be successful in predicting the future. The path to the goal is often achieved much more quickly by making an early decision followed by a course correction rather than waiting for all the information.

View Story

All About Flex: Flexible PCB: What’s in a Name?

11-12-2015

Flexible PCB is a common term that is synonymous with flexible circuits. While the term “PCB” is generally used to describe rigid printed circuitry, “flexible PCB” is a little contradictory because “boards” aren’t really flexible. Some companies, like All Flex, design and manufactures flexible PCBs, but not rigid PCBs. There are many similarities between the two, but also significant differences.

View Story

Plated Through-holes in Flexible Circuits

10-29-2015

There is probably no more important feature than the plated through-hole (also called via or via hole) with regard to the reliability and integrity of a flexible circuit. The through-hole provides electrical connection between insulated layers and enables electrical functionality on double-sided and multilayer flexible circuits.

View Story

Testing Flexible Circuits, Part 3: The Completed Flex Circuit

10-15-2015

Most flex houses perform a variety of tests on completed flexible circuits. The type, frequency, and complexity of these tests vary with customer and application. Test requirements are generally defined by the customer, but input is often solicited from the supplier during the quote process.

View Story

Testing Flexible Circuits, Part I: Requirements and Procedures

09-17-2015

In this first of a three part series regarding tests for flexible circuits, I will examine overall requirements and procedures; the second installment will focus on raw materials, and the third and final part will focus on testing for bare flexible circuit and circuit assemblies.

View Story

Catching Up to Yesterday

09-02-2015

Recently, KPMG, an international consultancy that operates as a network of member firms offering audit, tax and advisory services, came out with their 6th annual survey of manufacturing executives focusing on global manufacturing trends.

View Story

The Butterfly Effect

08-20-2015

If a random initial disturbance from the wings of a butterfly can have a dramatic effect, just think what can be accomplished with intentional acts aimed at making sure our customers are receiving proactive attention.

View Story

Is Wearable Technology Just a Fad?

08-13-2015

Wearable technology is in its infancy. The industry needs to mature and go back to basic marketing—finding a need and filling it. Flexible circuits have been around since the mid-1960s and have been successfully filling needs. Flexible circuits are ideal for wearable technology because they are thin and lightweight. As the marketing matures, the applications will come and flexible circuits will be there to fill the technical needs.

View Story

Unique Single-Sided Flexible Circuits

08-06-2015

The number of iterations, sequences and combinations possible when manufacturing a flexible circuit can create unique product features to reduce hand assembly of wires, create switch contacts, or eliminate connectors. With minor alterations in basic processing steps, a flex circuit applications engineer can often imagine and configure a dramatically different flexible circuit.

View Story

Agricultural Drones and Flexible Circuits

07-28-2015

According to MIT Technology Review, one of theTop 10 breakthrough technologies last year was the agricultural drone. I focused on drones in one of my recent columns, Flexible Circuits and UAV Applications, which briefly mentioned agriculture as one of the uses for drones.

View Story
Copyright © 2018 I-Connect007. All rights reserved.